Facebook Twitter/X LinkedIn Pinterest Reddit Blogger Tumblr WhatsApp Email Instapaper Stripe Tip PayPal Tip GoFundMe Buy Me a Coffee Patreon Medium Substack Instagram Threads

Teaching Jung in a Theological Seminary by Ann Belford Ulanov

92 / 100 SEO Score

Teaching Jung in a Theological Seminary by Ann Belford Ulanov

Here is the clean, formatted version of your text optimized for a WordPress post. All broken line breaks, hyphenated words split by lines (e.g., fi elds, identifi cation), and extra spaces have been corrected to ensure a smooth, professional layout.

The text is structured using standard HTML/WordPress paragraph spacing (a single clean line break between paragraphs) and includes appropriate header styling (## and ###) for easy readability on modern screens.

I read with great interest David Tacey’s article on teaching Jung in the academy and recognized in him a collegial spirit. For years only a few of us, as both clinicians and professors, have worked teaching theories of the unconscious in institutions of higher learning. The amazing fact about the unconscious—that it exists and is unconscious—raises fascinating problems in the teaching-learning context.

Psychic Reality

The teacher should not, I believe, do therapy in the classroom, for that violates students’ psyches. But neither should the teacher talk about the unconscious in a way that leads students into intellectual dissociation from the presence of the psyche right there in people in the classroom. What then can we do with the unconscious in the educational setting?

This problem is not faced only by teachers of depth psychology, but by all teachers of quality, those who teach material that matters. I think of two colleagues as examples. Both are men—one in the cross-disciplinary fields of literature, arts, and religion; the other in the discipline of speech analysis and training—who exhibit enormous skill, force, and tact. They stick to their material—the texts—and to the students’ reception and use of their matter, and they bring their students to the spirit of what matters. As a result, letters from students indicate, these teachers often change their students’ lives.

These men do not do therapy in the classroom. In the case of one man, his hearing a student’s true voice waiting to be liberated from inferiority or grandiosity complexes aids the unique unfolding of the student’s personality in the context of a particular spoken text. For some students, this acute listening transforms their lives.

In the other case, the man meets his students in the material they study together. He summons them into this matrix, asking them to open themselves to text, author, and cultural surroundings, that is, to bring and show themselves in response. His own passion for the material ignites theirs. A Jungian analyst I know, on hearing this teacher lecture publicly, said of him: “When I hear most lecturers I am often moved at the moment; when I hear this man, I go home and read and read.”

The letters this teacher receives from students, often years after the conclusion of the course, express thanks for his opening up the world of the material, in which the student was able to find what a Jungian analyst might call “the living psyche.”

For the teacher of theories about the unconscious psyche, the net tightens. We have to ask ourselves, What sort of tiger have we caught here? For we are, students and teachers alike, studying ourselves when we study such material. Unlike our analysts in training, our academic classroom students may or may not be in treatment themselves. The classroom gets crowded, filling up with hidden questions, unconscious questions put by our psyches, questions that we often resist hearing.

Each of us feeling this resistance is challenged to see if our objections to the psychological theories under discussion amount to a preference to work out our conflicts through generalized issues of social justice or theoretical constructions rather than acknowledging their personal roots. The room palpably fills up with the different levels of psychological development among the students, each registering, through individual confusion and bewilderment, different developmental imperatives.

Hermeneutical questions particularly crowd in on us. If as teachers we make room for different levels of development and a variety of resistances to a given psychological theory, understanding that it may be liberating to one student while judgmental for another, how do we go about the business of assessing the theory’s intrinsic truth? Is truth simply relative to various subjective viewpoints? Does a norm of truth still exist?

By what criteria can it be determined, demonstrated? Professor Tacey’s dramatic examples—of students and teachers either altogether excluding study of Jung’s theories or altogether embracing Jung to a point of identification that excludes critical reflection—fit here. In my own teaching and supervising of doctoral work in a graduate school of religion, the hermeneutic question reaches a further point of tension: Can something be psychologically true if it is theologically false (or vice versa)?

Seminary Context

Professor Tacey and I share the labor of teaching, but our contexts differ in significant ways. He teaches in a university setting, which, in common with American universities, prides itself on objectivity and critical inquiry, eschewing belief as countermanding those values. In many American educational contexts where Jung is most apt to be taught, the stance of faith is considered to be a drawback to effective teaching. Faith is somehow not rigorous enough or might contaminate the learning process with a proselytizing fervor.

Yet, as Tacey also underscores, the whole issue of belief, if thrown out the front door, will sneak in through the back. The clinician will recognize what Melanie Klein calls “the symbolic equation” as the unconscious condition informing any touted “objectivity.” Teachers, in other words, tend unconsciously to identify with what grips them as truth, and the resultant equation of themselves with their ideas acts as a coercive agent in the class discussions. Instances can occur of a teacher marking a student down for arguing against the teacher’s undeclared but powerfully operating “truth.” Tacey sums it up succinctly:

“There are theologies inside our theories, and articles of faith underpin most of our intellectual positions” (p. 269). In a religious institution, ironically, when differences of theology are being debated at a conscious intellectual level, beliefs sneak in, in the form of political ideologies. Here, the coercive symbolic equation is operating at the juncture of belief and action in society: theological doctrine that does not pay off in what is considered to be appropriate social action (praxis) is dismissed as bad theology.

My context—teaching in a theological seminary that is also a graduate school of religion—brings some different protections and strains from Tacey’s university setting. In a seminary, belief is not held to be a drawback but a resource—indeed, a link to the Source.

Belief in God, both personal and communal, acts like a pipeline to the energy and affect that can sustain studies and future careers. Such belief suggests the point of it all and answers the discouraged and cynical question we hear all the time: So what? Or What difference can anyone’s piddling efforts make in the face of such suffering in the world? The answer of belief circles around an ego attitude that witnesses to a reality greater than itself, greater in fact than all our selves, which gets expressed in such phrases as “for the sake of love” or “for the greater glory of God.”

The traditional religious vocabulary is handy, in that it offers both student and teacher a way to point to a transcendent purposiveness that is present here and now in our actions. Such a transpersonal referent should not be seen as diluting objectivity, but rather as endorsing it. From the perspective of the theological seminary, loss of the transcendent referent exposes us to equally unfortunate opposites: addiction to objectivity (all the while repressing subjective identification with one’s theory) and passionate overidentification with one’s point of view (disavowing one’s actual objective distance from the theory on which one has projected one’s personal complexes).

The religious awareness that pervades seminary education, that of a transcendent God that goes well beyond our particular God-images, offers the positive advantage of another perspective. In it, we include the opposites, instead of choosing one at the expense of the other and ending up in a ceaseless compensatory seesawing, acted out in the kind of community of opposing groups that Tacey bemoans. Ours is, I find, more of a muddle of conjunction than a tension of opposition.

My particular seminary, in contrast to schools of particular churches (such as the Presbyterian, the Episcopalian, and the Catholic) that operate from a shared symbol system of doctrine, is nondenominational. At the center of a nondenominational seminary a hole exists, an empty space where doctrinal demands might be expected.

In any given week at Union, for example, the schedule of daily worship will reflect the different and competing symbol systems of the school’s students and faculty.

A traditional Presbyterian service one day, consisting of sermon, prayers, and hymns, will be followed the next by a group of Catholics reciting the rosary.

Yet another day brings a service articulating protest against the unjust discrimination suffered by gays and lesbians, followed on its morrow by the presentation of the ineffable but tough faith that students working as hospital chaplains must draw on to survive their ministry to people in the grip of mental and physical illness. Different community groups take turns putting into the empty space at the center the symbols that best capture for them the reality of God. Together, we circle around this center in process, which acts like a revolving mandala, reflecting all our perspectives. At our best, we stimulate each other, feed each other, learn from each other.

At worst, the vertigo of this evolving space makes us feel that the center does not hold. Sometimes, we compete to fill it entirely with our particular God-images, seeking to foist them on each other with all kinds of bullying, even theological sadism, if others do not agree. As in other religious arguments, the struggle over religious perspective keeps increasing the stakes. Those who disagree are accused of unjust attitudes, prejudiced actions, and unfaithful behavior—modern versions of old fashioned “damnation.” Once, when asked what community life was like at Union, a colleague of mine (quoting Elijah, 1 Kings 19: 10b) said, “I, I alone am left, and they seek my life.”

Nonetheless, the apparently empty space at the center of a school like Union, which includes Christian students of all denominations and degrees of faith, some Jewish students and Greek Orthodox, a few Muslims, and people of all ages, classes, races, cultures, and sexual orientations, does offer always the potential of an extraordinary freedom. The gap in the symbol system at the center works for us because it mirrors the unavoidable gap between the finite and the infinite. Our communal and personal squabbles circle around our shared acknowledgment that nothing human can define an unfathomable God.

Teaching Jung

It is within this religious setting that our students study Jung and where I myself feel compelled to emphasize the gap between things finite and infinite. The fact that Jung is taught in conjunction with other major and conflicting theories of depth psychology constantly calls attention to definitive gaps and differences in all of them. The temptation to idolize Jung that Tacey describes is thus depotentiated because Jung’s theories are always looked at in relation to other maps of the psyche and varying intellectual contexts that are expected, like it, to miss the ultimate mark. We see again and again that no theory brings the last word of truth.

Our students in the Program of Psychiatry and Religion range across, in all, five programs leading to degrees, all of which contain large components of interdisciplinary conversations with religion as well as praxis. As a result, much of the attraction to and resistance against Jung’s work that Tacey describes shifts over to the dramatic experience of the psyche per se.

The teaching of Jung or any other depth psychologist occurs, then, as a way of dealing with the theoretical and practical issues that surround people learning to work in a parish, a hospital, a prison, a classroom, or a clinical setting with people suffering emotional illness, and it becomes yet another way to aid persons’ spiritual development in prayer, worship, and practice and to adjust to widely differing cultural contexts both here and abroad.

The seminary setting helps to position students to see through theories to the transcendent itself and, conversely, to test theory against the practical and intellectual labor of discerning whether a point of view aids or obstructs human efforts to live justly and walk humbly with one’s God. For the seminary training ministers, social workers, future religious teachers and publishers, and scholars of religion, all under one roof, the proof is in the pudding. Intellectual learning couples inexorably with professional vocation.

Students who concentrate in psychiatry and religion train for all those professions and move on, many of them to become chaplain-teachers in medical or mental hospitals and for clinical ministries such as those of pastoral counselors. A steady number of students seek additional education in the training institute of whatever school of depth psychology draws them to become analysts.

A student at the doctoral level may choose the option of training at both Union and a training institute at the same time in order to be able to teach at the graduate or undergraduate level and also to practice as a clinician. Thus, students studying Jung at Union do so within the context of highly demanding theoretical and professional training and with the constant experience of an ongoing interdisciplinary conversation that seeks to explore the impact of psychic reality on religious life and thought. For these students, the psyche has become an unmistakable

and clearly delineated reality. A recognition that the psyche exists and that a goodly portion of it exists unconsciously distinguishes the particular city of psychiatry and religion within the country of the larger seminary.

Controversy

Taken as a whole, Union holds a firmly and widely established reputation as a seminary committed to social action, and it is fair to say that it is not a psychologically minded community. The dismissal, scorn, and sheer ignorance of psychic reality that Tacey describes in his world can be found in ours, too.

It is an attitude applied with equal repressive force to all of depth psychology, not just to Jung. Jung may, however, be singled out as particularly offensive, as an essentialist who perpetuates sexual stereotypes, as a thinker who ignores historical and political contexts, as one who is too individualistic at the expense of community needs, and as one, not least in offensiveness, who substitutes a psychological universe for the religious one.

Neither Jung’s nor any other analyst’s theories are used in fields outside psychiatry and religion to augment methods of interpretation of scripture, doctrine, historical movements, or the problems of ethical discernment. Preference in the practice of general theology is given to the more extroverted hermeneutics that emphasize the sociopolitical context and the sociology of knowledge.

The rejection of depth psychological theories in even this liberal setting comes down, I find, to the fear of the psyche, with peculiar accent on what I have called the Christian fear of psychic reality.[1] I have even had the experience of teaching a student who said she felt she was betraying her other teachers’ loyalty to social justice by taking a course in psychiatry and religion, only to find out how different the material was from all her expectations, that is, her projections and projective identifications. Indeed, a particularly fascinating subject to students and even to some colleagues entering the field for the first time is the role of the unconscious in social action causes and concerns.

Psychiatry and Religion

Within the Psychiatry and Religion Program, students study the primary texts of depth psychology from all the major schools and perspectives. We read Freud, Jung, Adler, Horney, Rank, Laing, Odier, Kohut, Kernberg, Klein, Boss, Binswanger, Bion, Frankl, Erikson, Winnicott, Guntrip, Fairbairn, Bollas, McDougall, Milner, Chasseguet-Smirgel, Lacan, Stern, Khan, Loewald, Bromberg, Atwood, Ogden, Grand, Symington, Kristeva, Von Franz, Layton, Bowen, Minuchin, Weigert, Sullivan, Searles, and others.

My own strong bias toward Jung, which I announce openly in class, is stated to urge students to pay close attention to those theories that either beckon or repel them, for I think that will invariably indicate their most fruitful path to relate to psychic reality. I stress that all the theories studied possess some truth, for they all have arisen out of clinical work with the psyche and would not have survived if they had not proved lifesaving to the soul of someone.

I encourage students to lift into explicit conversation that inner dialogue with the depths of the psyche that has been going on their whole lives. I want them to work to find their own voices in that conversation, not to aim at duplication of Freud or Jung or Klein or me, their teacher. In preparing their exams and papers, I invite, prod, and even cajole students to concentrate on material that is hot for them, for that always fosters meaningful creative work that captures the imagination of others.

The space provided for such confrontations is constructed by me, by the students, and by the material. In Christian terms, this triangulation of space calls up images of the Trinity God’s inner-object relations, of who and what God is when God is not doing anything. In that space, the students and I contribute our presentations, insights, and questions in relation to the specific material we study. When a synergy gets going, where energy flows out to each other and to the material, and back and forth among the three participants—the teacher, the student, the material—then I know the space is alive. Associations, connections occur.

The level of ego tasks—mastering the material, applying, for example, the theory of unconscious projections to preaching to a depressed parishioner, grasping the role unconscious anxiety plays in the positions taken by a far-right or far-left political group, inquiring how sexual issues with an inner-anima figure can both impede and advance spiritual growth—begins to differentiate from archetypal levels at which it is possible to inquire in a living context into what symbols the psyche employs to speak of itself and in what ways this objective psychic reality relates to the spirit or the divine.

Excitement heats up, and the new arrives. We face it—in thought, in new connections, in feelings, in body impulses—right there in class. We know we are alive.

Including the Unconscious

As I have indicated, fear of the psyche, existing immediately within us, between us, and unfolding our uniqueness in response to its own manifestations, lies behind all opposition to depth psychological material in the curriculum. It is a sad commentary on us as a tribe in higher education to note that we have managed to distance ourselves from the hot coals of poetry, mathematics, the classical languages, history, and all the other disciplines of preparatory study so that we can talk about them without passion, without any fear they will still burn our lips (Isaiah 6:7). Study of the psyche, on the other hand, is still new enough to arouse a primitive awe, fear, and fascination.

A student from nearby Columbia University, with which Union has close connections and some joint degree programs, obtained permission to take an introductory course I teach in depth psychology and theology, though his professor warned him it would be “too soft.” The student exclaimed at term’s end that he had worked “more than twice as hard” as in his Columbia psychology courses, not only to cover the quantity of reading assigned but also to keep up with all that leaped up in response within himself.

Here, I would disagree with what I experience as Professor Tacey’s implicit and explicit criticism of religion, though I found very interesting his Oedipally tinged interpretation of students’ preferences for either Freud (father) or Jung (mother). Tacey’s interpretation of religion and of Jung seems to me to be too reductive—as only a return to the womb and the all-embracing maternal unconscious that bans critical thought and locates authority only in dreams, fantasies, and intuitions from within, while eschewing external standards of judgment and comparison.

I found implied in this description of students’ attraction to Jung a notion of religion as uncritical, anti-intellectual, immature, clinging, embarrassing, and, in public behavior, eventually fanatic. What seems to me to be lacking in this interpretation is any notion of the epigenesis of religious feeling, of the fact that it develops and differentiates, that it draws upon intellect, texts, historical communities, and mature presentiments of the divine Other.

If we apply Jung’s method of prospective interpretation to Tacey’s description of students’ attraction to Jung as regression to maternal incest, we will be led to agree with Jung that Oedipal conflict can conceal the hidden purpose of seeking union with oneself and with the Self. From the prospective standpoint, one seeks one’s own foundations in the psyche, not to disappear in the maternal womb, but to be born out of it with one’s own point of view. One then emerges, not as a committed Jungian or any other kind of follower, but as secure and original in one’s thought and convictions and altogether free to inquire intellectually and emotionally as one feels moved to do so.

The issue that I think unites all of us who teach depth psychology in higher education and in seminary training rests on the need to include the fact of the unconscious in the curriculum. Here, Jung’s notion of the unconscious offers special benefits, recognizing, as it does, a purposiveness in the unconscious in relation to consciousness.

The extreme reactions of scornful rejection and idolatrous adoption to Jung’s theories that Professor Tacey describes spring, I believe, not from hollow people, but from hollow studies. When students read Jung, something happens that can frighten as much as fascinate. This strong kind of emotional and intellectual reaction—where the student’s ego feels gripped by archetypal energy—may not, sadly, be happening in their other courses.

Perhaps in studying Jung, who himself studied the living psyche, the connections between archetypal and ego levels occur more immediately than in the study of other theorists and theories, where the unconscious is approached from the ego point of view, thus to be translated upward into conscious concepts.[2] Jung’s great gift was to hit upon easily experienceable symbols that speak for the unconscious directly, symbols like the shadow, the inner woman, the Self, the persona as public mask. As a consequence, people flee or embrace Jung because they either fear or long for connection to the living psyche.

Yet whether in the profession of religion, in clinical practice, or in higher education, what people look for, I believe, is precisely such a conjunction of the enduring and the immediate. Professor Tacey evidently has had to face the extremes of repudiation or identification with Jung’s theories, in a kind of sequential and compensating either-or. Our besetting questions at Union seem more often to spring from conjunctions.

Perhaps it is the religious container that lends weight to the urgent questions our professors commonly hear, of how to live the All in the here and now, how to love the whole while making a concrete choice of one path rather than another, how to serve the psyche and recognize in it and through it the Holy that speaks to each of us in the narratives and dramas of our dreams.

Speaking for myself, I see the study of depth psychology as an essential preparation for the religious professions, and in particular the study of Jung. Jung’s vision, in my view, is larger than what others offer. Jung reaches to the psyche that exists objectively in our subjectivity, addressing us, pushing, prodding, luring us to meet its unfolding as we try to construct meaning, individually and collectively.[3]

I find that we enter a new zone of communication when we accept the fact of psychic reality. Then we are able to see the processes of unconscious mentation in our social, political, and family life, as well as in our inner conversation with ourselves. Surely we see in the psyche an incomparable witnessing to the mystery that invokes us and undergirds our callings.[4] What Jung inaugurated was not just another treatment modality for emotional distress; it was a new way to perceive reality.

— Ann Belford Ulanov, Teaching Jung, Teaching Jung in a Theological Seminary, Page 51-59

Notes

[1] A. B. Ulanov, “The Christian Fear of the Psyche,” in Picturing God (Einsiedeln, Switzerland, 1986/2005A), 5–23.

[2] A. Ulanov and B. Ulanov, Religion and the Unconscious (Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox, 1975), 65–68.

[3] A. B. Ulanov, Spiritual Aspects of Clinical Work (Einsiedeln, Switzerland: Daimon 2004), 326–330.

[4] A. B. Ulanov, The Unshuttered Art: Opening Aliveness/ Deadness in the Self (Nashville, TN: Abingdon 2007), 230–231, 239–242.

Carl Jung Depth Psychology Blog

Carl Jung Instagram

007 teachers
007 teachers
119 teaching
119 teacher
1N teacher
teach teach teach teach teach teach teach teach teach teach teach teach teach teach teach teach
1teacher
teach

 

 

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.