To Josef Goldbrunner

Dear Dr. Goldbrunner, 8 February 1941

Very many thanks for kindly sending me your book on my psychology.

I read it at once and was impressed by your careful exposition and the trouble you have taken over your task, which was surely not an easy one.

A fundamental misunderstanding has crept into it, however, for which I wouldn’t like to hold you entirely responsible.

You evidently did not know that epistemologically I take my stand on Kant, which means that an assertion doesn’t posit its object.

So when I say “God” I am speaking exclusively of assertions that don’t posit their object.

About God himself I have asserted nothing, because according to my premise nothing whatever can be asserted about God himself.

All such assertions refer to the psychology of the God-image.

Their validity is therefore never metaphysical but only psychological.

All my assertions, reflections, discoveries, etc. have not the remotest connection with theology but are, as I have said, only statements about psychological facts.

This self-limitation which is absolutely essential in psychology is generally overlooked, whereupon this disastrous confusion arises, with the result that it looks as if I were presuming to make metaphysical judgments.

Again with best thanks and kindest regards,

Yours sincerely,

C.G. Jung ~Carl Jung, Letters Vol. 1, Pages 293-294.

Liked it? Take a second to support lewislafontaine on Patreon!